- Billie-Jo Grant, PhD
Accommodations and Inclusivity in Sports for Transgender Students
School district administrators need to consider how to accommodate transgender students participating in Athletics. First, they should look to see if there are any state laws, if there is no state law or their state law does not provide guidance, consider creating a policy to address how transgender students should be accommodated, so these decisions are not left to each site administrator.
Recently, the issue of whether transgender students are eligible to participate in sports has become a widely discussed topic, with each state having its own laws concerning this matter.
There is a debate over whether there is an unfair advantage that men might have when competing against women, which is why Olympic sports utilize hormone testing and DNA testing to prevent men from competing in women's events. In general, it is still widely accepted that most men possess a physical advantage over the majority of women.
This has been an ongoing issue for many years, presenting difficulties for transgender students who want to participate in sports but must abide by the regulations set out by their respective states. We should all consider the following questions rather than relying on political pundits when debating the issue of transgender athletes: Does a third-grade transgender girl have any physical advantage over a cisgender girl of the same age? Is there still an advantage for a fifteen-year-old transgender girl, who has been taking puberty-blocking drugs for three years? Does prohibiting transgender athletes from participating in a school team that matches their gender identity constitute sex discrimination under Title IX? Answering these questions accurately and fairly can help us determine the best path forward. Lawmakers, courts, and schools are struggling to answer the question of whether transgender girls should be allowed to compete on girls' sports teams. Some states have passed laws prohibiting it, while others have proposed similar bans. Courts tend to focus on the harm done to individual students when they are not able to participate, considering the potential for an unfair advantage. There is debate surrounding the issue of whether transgender girls should be allowed to compete in female sports, as some people argue that it will take away opportunities from cisgender girls and that they have a physical edge. Nonetheless, there is no such proof for these claims, and since allowing transgender athletes to participate, the number of cisgender girls participating in sports has grown. School districts may consider evaluating each athlete on an individual basis, taking into account the sport and their particular circumstances.
However, the decision of whether or not to allow transgender girls to compete in female sports is complex, and there are no easy answers. Ultimately, what matters most is ensuring everyone has a fair chance at participating in sports. All athletes should have the opportunity to show their skill and ability on an equal playing field. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) recently removed its rule that required transgender athletes to have a certain level of hormones in their bodies, as there was no evidence to suggest this gave them an unfair advantage. It is now up to the organization governing each individual sport to decide whether transgender athletes can compete. Organizations such as the International Federation of Swimming and the International Rugby League have already established their own policies on this matter. The NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic Association) has stated that it will abide by these decisions made by individual sports organizations.
The Difference Between Gender Identity and Sex Assigned at Birth
It is important to understand the difference between gender identity and sex assigned at birth. Sex is determined by biology, as it is based on physical attributes like anatomy and chromosomes. Gender identity, however, refers to an individual's internal sense of their own gender. Someone's gender identity may be different from the sex assigned at birth; for instance, someone with a female sex assigned at birth may identify as male. Gender expression is the way in which an individual expresses their gender identity, such as through clothing, hairstyle, voice, or behavior. A person's gender expression does not necessarily need to match their gender identity; for example, someone who identifies as male may express their gender in a feminine way.
Transgender Participation in K-12 Athletics: Challenges and Solutions
Here are key considerations for school district administrators to consider as they create policies and procedures regarding transgender student participation:
Consider allowing transgender athletes to participate in accordance with their gender identity rather than their sex assigned at birth.
Consider providing access to bathrooms and locker rooms that correspond with the athlete’s gender identity. Some states have already implemented laws regarding locker room access and researchers have concluded that this access has helped to reduce potential stigmatization and bullying.
Consider using the athlete’s preferred name and pronouns when referring to them. Studies have shown this will make them feel more comfortable and accepted in their environment.
Protecting the confidentiality of the athlete’s transgender status can help ensure that they are not subjected to any unwanted or undue attention. Finally,
Providing training for coaches and staff on working with transgender athletes will help ensure that they are treated fairly and with respect while participating in activities.
By taking all of these steps, K-12 schools can create an environment that is comfortable, safe, and inclusive for all participants, regardless of their gender identity. It is important for K-12 schools to implement policies and practices that are nondiscriminatory toward transgender athletes while still respecting their individual rights. Ultimately, the creation of policies and procedures will help ensure that transgender athletes are treated fairly and with respect, which will help foster an environment of acceptance and understanding in K-12 schools. With the right protocols in place depending on the state, K-12 schools can create a safe and welcoming environment for all of their athletes.
Anti-Discrimination Education in K-12 Schools
In order to create a safe and inclusive environment for all students, K-12 schools could provide anti-discrimination training. This type of training would cover topics related to working with transgender athletes, such as understanding their needs and creating an inclusive environment. Understanding the laws that protect transgender athletes in each state is also essential in avoiding discrimination in K-12 sports. To learn more about how to identify and address discrimination in K-12 schools, consider taking one of our training courses.
McGrath Training Solutions has compiled a summary of each state’s current laws, along with Title IX regulations and their changes, to help organizations stay in compliance with state and federal laws. Our services also include training, policy reviews, compliance checks, climate surveys, and reviews of best practices to help ensure a safe and inclusive environment for staff and students.